A dump truck tire failure caused a multi-vehicle interstate crash that left a union carpenter with permanent injuries and unable to work. With limited insurance available, MRH Injury Law dug deeper to identify additional liable parties and sources of compensation.
What You Need to Know
- The accident: A dump truck tire blew out on an interstate, sending the truck through the median and cable barrier into oncoming traffic, where it struck multiple vehicles.
- The injuries: Our client suffered extensive internal injuries and a significant traumatic brain injury and would never be able to return to work.
- The challenge: With multiple people injured and killed in the crash, it was clear early on that the dump truck’s available insurance would not be enough to compensate everyone for their losses.
- The strategy: MRH Injury Law investigated beyond the initial accident to identify other parties whose actions contributed to the crash and who had their own insurance coverage.
- The result: That investigation identified three additional avenues of liability and insurance coverage, which provided compensation for our client’s catastrophic injuries and long-term needs.
The Case
What happened?
Our client was a middle-aged man who had spent his career as a union carpenter. He was traveling to a jobsite with a friend and coworker when a dump truck traveling on the interstate experienced a catastrophic tire failure.
The dump truck’s front drive tire blew out, causing the truck to plow through the median and cable barrier and into oncoming traffic. The truck struck several vehicles, including the pickup truck in which our client was a passenger.
Our client’s friend and coworker was killed in the crash.
Our client survived but suffered extensive internal injuries and a significant traumatic brain injury. His injuries were so severe that it was clear he would never be able to return to his career. He also faced a lifetime of medical treatment and the financial consequences that come with a permanent, life-changing injury.
The Legal Challenge
What happens when there isn’t enough insurance to cover a catastrophic injury?
In a serious multi-vehicle crash, the available insurance coverage may need to be divided among multiple injured people and families who have suffered devastating losses.
Early in the case, it became clear that there likely would not be enough insurance to cover all of the damages resulting from the crash.
That presented a critical question: Were there other parties who could be held responsible and who had their own insurance policies?
Rather than simply accept the available coverage, MRH Injury Law dug deeper.
How MRH Injury Law Dug Deeper
1. Investigating the Dump Truck’s Tire
The investigation first focused on why the dump truck’s tire failed.
MRH Injury Law discovered that the tire was too old and too worn to be safely used, that’s why the tire blew. More importantly, the tire had actually been sold to the dump truck owner after it had expired. It was older than the dump truck itself.
The tire never should have been placed on the market or installed on the dump truck.
Based on those findings, MRH Injury Law pursued a products liability claim against the shop that sold the tire.
The shop’s insurance carrier ultimately paid its policy limits.
2. Investigating Who Was Controlling the Dump Truck Driver
The investigation then uncovered evidence that another company had been dispatching and partially controlling the dump truck.
Text messages produced during the lawsuit showed that the trucking company was telling the dump truck driver where to go and when to go there.
That evidence raised an important legal question: Was the dump truck driver acting as an agent of the trucking company when the crash occurred?
MRH Injury Law sued the trucking company, asserting that the dump truck was their agent at the time of the crash.
Its insurance carrier also paid its policy limits.
3. Investigating the Construction Company’s Role
MRH Injury Law continued investigating the relationships behind the dump truck’s work.
The investigation revealed that a large construction company was ultimately controlling the dump truck’s work as it hauled materials for a nearby project.
The construction company was determining where the dump truck should go to pick up loads, when it should go, what it should haul, and where it should deliver those loads.
Those facts supported another agency theory of liability.
MRH Injury Law sued the construction company, and its insurance company also paid its policy limits.
How Did Digging Deeper Change the Outcome?
The initial concern was straightforward: There was not enough insurance to compensate everyone harmed in the crash.
But the initial insurance coverage wasn’t the end of the investigation.
By examining the condition and history of the dump truck’s tire, reviewing communications involving the truck driver, and investigating who controlled the truck’s work, MRH Injury Law identified three additional parties with potential legal responsibility and their own insurance coverage.
Each insurance carrier paid its policy limits.
As someone who suffered catastrophic injuries, lost his ability to work, and faced a lifetime of medical care, that additional recovery provided real, necessary compensation to our client. Here’s Why Our Clients Love Results That Exceed Expectations.
Why This Case Matters
Does not having enough insurance mean there is no way to recover full compensation?
Not necessarily.
In a serious injury case, it is important to identify every potentially responsible party and determine whether each party has insurance coverage that may apply.
That requires more than simply identifying the driver who caused the crash. Depending on the circumstances, liability may extend to businesses, employers, contractors, manufacturers, product sellers, or other parties whose actions contributed to the accident.
In this case, digging deeper uncovered multiple potential sources of liability and insurance coverage that were not apparent from the initial investigation.
Attorney Perspective
“When I saw the number of people injured in this crash and the extent of the damages, I knew early on that there likely wouldn’t be enough insurance. We had to dig deeper to find out who else was responsible and whether they had insurance policies that could provide additional compensation.”
— Matt Meyerkord, Attorney, MRH Injury Law
When the Stakes Are High, Dig Deeper
Catastrophic injuries can affect every part of your life, from your ability to work and support your family to your need for lifelong medical care.
At MRH Injury Law, we dig deeper to understand what happened, identify every potentially responsible party, and pursue the compensation our clients need for the road ahead. Here’s Why Clients Choose MRH Injury Law for Personal Injury Cases in Kansas City.
If you or a loved one has suffered a serious injury, contact MRH Injury Law to learn how we can help.
Key Takeaways
- The first insurance policy may not be the only source of compensation. When multiple parties contributed to an accident, each may have separate insurance coverage.
- Finding additional sources of recovery requires investigation. Evidence about a defective product, business relationships, communications, and control over work can reveal additional liability.
- Catastrophic injury cases require looking beyond the immediate accident. When an injury permanently affects someone’s ability to work and requires lifelong medical care, identifying every potential source of compensation matters.
Results Disclaimer: Every case is different, and results depend on the specific facts and circumstances. Past results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future case.